The verdant expanse of Aarey forests in suburban Mumbai turned into a battleground between environmentalists and authorities. Triggering this confrontation was the BMC-appointed Tree Authority’s clearance to cut almost 2,700 trees in the area to construct a car shed for the upcoming metro line.
This controversy expectedly reignited the development vs. environment debate. In a space-starved and congested city like Mumbai, Sanjay Gandhi National Park and Aarey are the few open green spaces left. Rich in biodiversity, home to several animals and birds and with lakhs of trees, the Aarey forests are the lungs of the city.
Environmentalists fear that this mass felling of trees will disturb the whatever ecological balance Mumbai still retains and can exacerbate chronic problems like flooding.
It has not been an easy ride for the state government over the last few days. Environmentalists and activists have staged a massive protest against the felling of trees and MHADA’s move to acquire more land from Aarey Colony for building other metro sheds. In a major victory for these protestors most recently, the government has decided to shelve its plan to acquire more land from Aarey and instead sought an alternate land parcel spread over 28,000 sq. ft. area at Wadala in the south eastern region.
That said, as of now, the earlier proposal to cut down 2,700 trees continues.
The issues at hand are complex and tricky. Mumbai is in desperate need of enhanced public transport solutions, and the metro will address the commuting requirements of tens of thousands of suburbanites. But should development come at the cost of the environment? The damage done by hacking close to three thousand trees may be irreparable and could have long-term consequences for the city.
Real Estate and Social Implications
While the Metro will benefit residents living around the Aarey forests by reducing their daily commute time, the construction of a Metro car shed is unlikely to have any direct real estate benefit. It is only a parking lot and service area for Metro trains.
However, the state government has also allotted 90 acres of land inside Aarey forests to rehabilitate tribals and slum dwellers. In fact, the Maharashtra Housing and Area Development Authority (MHADA) has also floated tenders to build homes for slum dwellers from Maroshi in Andheri and tribals from Sanjay Gandhi National Park.
The construction of SRA projects unlocks prime land opening up many possibilities for developers – but again, the development of an SRA project in an ecologically sensitive area like Aarey brings up its own environmental questions.
This SRA project has met with much opposition due to its potentially negative impact on the local environment and ecosystem. Tribals on their part are also resisting this development and have protested against moving to rehabilitation buildings. Indigenous to the Aarey area, these tribals have been demanding better welfare for their community.
Ideally, rehabilitation of slum dwellers must be near their original place of residence. It is definitely not feasible, either economically or socially, to transplant a large group of people to a new location in the city and expect them to find new means of livelihood and survival.
However, there must be enough land available to rehabilitate slum dwellers near their original residence – which is also tough in a city of Mumbai.
Availability of land in prime areas is the biggest hurdle infrastructure developers face when it comes to projects in metro cities. The problem is even more acute in Mumbai, which is primarily an island city that can only grow northwards.
A recent tweak to Development Control (DC) rules governing slum rehabilitation projects by the state government has opened fresh avenues for developers. Developers can now avail construction benefits for building rental houses for the economically weaker sections and developing transit camps for slum dwellers.
This provision can be seen as a windfall for developers as the benefit has been extended from the suburbs to the island city. However, this essentially means developing rental accommodation and transit camps in the distant suburbs, several kilometres away from the original residence of slum dwellers.
True, developers benefit as land prices in the far-off suburbs are much lower than in the island city. Mumbai’s DC Rules permit developers a zonal FSI of 1.33 in the island city, while an SRA scheme gives them an FSI of 3. This means that the builder can develop as much as three times of the plot size. From a monetary point of view, the developer certainly gains from SRA development and relocating the original residents to another part of the city.
But again, this equation does not factor in how the slum dwellers themselves would be affected.
Unsold inventory down to 32 months by 2021-end, close to 2019 Levels
Mumbai, January 17, 2022: The Indian residential property market held its own in 2021, with sales rebounding to more than...
Organic farm in TDI township
Mohali, January 17, 2022 : TDI Infratech has tied-up with Edible Routes a start-up in organic farming.The tie-up offers environment...
Xenius Solutions offer variety of benefits to businesses of all sizes
Source:https://www.xenius.in/xenius-solutions-offer-variety-of-benefits-to-businesses-of-all-sizes/ Business establishments of any size can reap immense benefits with the use of Xenius Solutions. As these are an...
Last block of Ashiana Nirmay launched
New Delhi/Bhiwadi, Jan 15, 2022: Ashiana Housing on Saturday announced the launch of the last block of Ashiana Nirmay, its senior...
Lohri celebrations at Sikka Gp’s societies
NCR based developer, Sikka Group celebrated this year’s Lohri at three of their Noida based projects- Sikka Karnam (Sector143 B),...
Pashmina Waterfront gets Skating Rink!
Bengaluru, January 14, 2022: The residents of Pashmina Waterfront received a ‘Makar Sankranti’ Gift with the inauguration of the new...
News3 weeks ago
Mumbai, Bengaluru, Hyderabad to be frontrunners in residential real estate recovery in 2022: Housing.com IRIS index
News4 weeks ago
Nearly 80% of occupiers prioritize physical offices, want employees back in office, says CBRE’s India Future of Office Survey 2021
Guest Column4 weeks ago
Residential Real Estate – Highlights 2021
Report4 weeks ago
The future of co-living in India – Colliers
News2 weeks ago
Vigor Media Productions announces biopic movie on WB CM Mamata Banerjee
Guest Column3 weeks ago
Scope of Container Homes in India
News6 days ago
ARETE Group introduces Experience Centre for Flagship project, Payal Industrial Park
Report4 weeks ago
IT/ITeS, Infrastructure Drive Growth in Telangana – CREDAI-ANAROCK Report